Title: AYODHYA   The Dark Night

Authors: Krishna Jha and Dhirendra K Jha

Publishers: Harper Collins, India

Price:  Rs.499.00

THIS REVIEW WAS WRITTEN SOME TIME AGO- THE BOOK IS NOT WELL PUBLICISED.
There is a breed of people who will do anything in their pursuit of power and furtherance of political ambitions. One of the oldest weapons has been the use of religion as a tool to attain these goals. History is replete with examples of God being used and abused to whip up emotions and create a divide amongst people. Faith is a personal thing and should not be a weapon to divide people.

The Hindu Mahasabha which was the arm trying to form a “Hindu” nation used several strategies to try and achieve their objective. One of them was to ‘recapture’ Babri Masjid and create a “Ram Janmabhoomi”. This episode is shrouded in mystery and the problem still has to be resolved. It is a moot question as to whether a solution can be found that will please everyone. Surely, there will be politicians on either side of the fence, waiting to ignite passions.

The events of that night are re-constructed by narratives from persons who were there. The entire plot hatched by politicians with active participation from the local administrative person goes through with some hitches. From a key team of three, one backs out and the other two are left to accomplish their mission. The police and the security are manipulated to look elsewhere. And the local District Magistrate, KKK Nair aids and actively abets the installation of the idol and keeps the law at bay. And this was presumably with the blessing of the then Chief Minister of United Provinces, Shri G B Pant.

The interesting thing is that before the idol was installed, there were three or four ‘akhadas’. The word ‘akhada’ (or akhara) means a group. Each of the akhadas, till the grand conspiracy, claimed itself to house the birth of Ram. The akhadas (Nirmohi akhada which claims ownership of the disputed place, means a group without attachment), whilst claiming to worship one hindu God or the other, were generally at each other’s throats. Violence between akhadas was common.

This conspiracy did get the idol in to the masjid and then followed fights between akhadas for the management of the new “Ramjanmabhoomi”. The cash collections itself was a big lure. And the Hindu mahasabha had its act ready. The idol was installed in the middle of the night and posters announcing the ‘miracle’ were all over the place before sunrise! The local administration was an active accomplice in this incident.

“Ayodhya- The Dark Night” is a docu-drama that aims to reconstruct the night when an idol of the Hindu God Rama was placed inside the Babri Masjid. The authors, Krishna Jha and Dhirendra K. Jha are two journalists who have dug up archives of old newspapers, magazines and interviewed hundreds of people to try and piece together the drama on the night that the idol was placed inside the mosque. What has come out is a book that reads like a thriller, with the dramatis personae sketched out and the dastardly actions of the politicians, the religious heads and the administration in perpetuating this act clearly brought out.

It is a brilliant effort and is a read for all of us who have not delved in to history and merely follow the television media or rely on hearsay and come to biased opinions. Many of us may not be aware of the India that was in the period between independence and the adoption of our Constitution and one facet of the battle between fundamentalism and secularism is brought out well in this book. We all have a general view on history but rarely do we go deeply behind an event.

Each group of participants- the religious sects, the civil servants and the politicians are united by the common thread of acquiring wealth and property and religion is merely a platform. The multiple sects of the Hindus want control over the Ram Janmabhoomi to control the money that flows in. The civil servants use their clout to create divides and usurp property and money and the politician wants to have voter base to remain in power. All of this is brought out with names documented.

Since this is a reconstruction of events, with narrators giving their version, there could be elements of fabrication or distortion in the book. However, the main plot seems credible, though there is no conclusive evidence of any one individual being named. Names thrown about include Veer Savarkar to a Mahant Digvijay Nath (who was also accused of the murder of Mahatma Gandhi and then let off).

The book also raises several questions. Why do we have ‘state’ and ‘central’ demarcations when it comes to law and order? It was relevant during the fateful night at Ayodhya and is equally relevant today. Why do politicians let things fester and remain indecisive? Prolonging a problem simply because they think it may hurt some pocket of their votebank has become a standard procedure. Why do political parties use faith as a tool at all? Why do we as people meekly keep quiet? Are we so lost in our day to day existence that we tolerate the politicians and continuously ruin the country for future generations?

After reading this book, if you have merely followed your text books on history, you will change your perceptions on so many leaders of the past. Sadly, none of them come out as heroes. Clearly, Ayodhya issue could have been frozen within twenty four hours of its happening if the administration and the politicians had a will to act firmly. Alas, each one was worried about his own seat of power. After reading this, we also realise how the present set of leaders are obfuscating the issues and goading people with half-truths, if not total lies.
The authors also have given their views on events as reconstructed. One may or may not agree with their views and biases. Even if you take them away, there is enough left for the reader to form his own views. Whilst one may challenge the details of the history as reconstructed, there is enough to give you a broad outline. Whether each and every nuance of the conspiracy has come out is not material.

India won its independence to become one nation after a long battle with the English.  With its multitude of religious sects and sub-sects, India has become a fertile ground for politicians to use religion as a stepping stone to power and wealth. How long back in history will each one go behind the other for retribution or retaliation? Will our tomorrows be ruined by yesterdays?

 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s